Is the Music Industry Going the Way of the Newspaper Industry?

The newspaper industry has had to grapple with a seismic shift in user behaviour over the last 15 years: people just aren’t buying newspapers in the numbers they used to and crucially newspaper buyers are getting older, to the extent that the long term prognosis is for the bulk of newspaper buyers to die off….literally.  The irony (in a cosmic irony Alanis Morissette-type usage of the word rather than literal irony) is that more people are consuming more news than ever before, and young people too.  But most of that consumption is online and free. What newspapers haven’t yet figured out is how to turn this into a business, and all the while (to mix my clichéd metaphors) watching their cash cow whither on the vine.  The reason for this potted history of the 21st century newspaper industry is that it is looking increasingly the case that the music industry is arriving at a worryingly similar place.

Another year of digital stasis.  With 2011 sales figures beginning to come in, the scale of digital music’s recent underperformance is becoming increasingly clear.  In the UK overall music sales continued to decline with digital some way off yet from being able to pick up the slack.  The UK’s record label trade body the BPI reported that digital growth wasn’t enough to prevent a 5.4% decline in total album sales.  The picture was more positive in the US with Nielsen reporting that album sales actually grew for the first time since 2004, up 1.3% on last year.

But the US and UK numbers aren’t quite all they seem.  Both the BPI’s and Nielsen’s numbers are for unit sales.  One of the consumer benefits of the music industry meltdown has been aggressive discounting, with labels and retailers having to slash prices to persuade us to buy in numbers.  While this is great for music fans it means weaker profits for labels and that revenue sales trends are weaker than volume trends.  And that means that the UK revenue decline will likely be worse than 5.4% and that US revenues may well be down on 2011 despite the positive performance in units terms.  With a decade of digital sales already behind us this is the stage where digital sales growth should be rocketing and lifting the whole market with it.

The continued dominance of the CD. Albums are by far the most valuable component of music sales and despite positive digital growth the album remains largely unaffected by digital.  76% of album sales in UK are CDs and in the US the rate rises to a whopping 82%.  When the CD hurts the music industry hurts.   Nearly half of the growth in US albums sales came from increased CD sales.  Perhaps even more concerning is that three quarters of all US albums sales are offline.   Thus the music industry is depending on non-net-savvy consumers who don’t even buy online for the lion’s share of their income.  And CD buyers aren’t spring chickens either: nearly 40% of them are over 45.  On either count that is not exactly future-proofed revenue.  The echoes of the aging newspaper audience are depressingly obvious.

The CD: the Music Industry’s Heroin (and not in the female hero sense of the word).  Another similarity between the newspapers and record labels is their addiction to their respective dying formats. The direct consequence of poorly performing digital revenue strategies is that physical revenues become all the more important which in turn makes labels and newspapers less willing to pursue ambitious digital strategies that might hurt physical sales.  Which of course results in digital sales underperforming further and the whole thought process starts again.  This circular logic begets strategic paralysis.  Unless the record labels learn how to kick their CD habit they’re going to find themselves presiding over perennial long term decline.

The danger of ‘the Adele Effect’.  Both the UK and US sales numbers were dominated by Adele, with her landmark album ‘21’ topping charts in both markets and selling over 13 million copies (becoming the biggest selling album in a single year in the UK).  Uniquely well-performing albums like ‘21’ have a habit of creating reality distortion fields.  As I explained in a previous post Adele, along with Coldplay, is an increasingly rare breed: an album artist.  Adele and Coldplay both appeal to the older album buyer (which is exactly why Coldplay won’t let ‘Mylo Xyloto’ go on Spotify until sales have peaked).  The strong performance of both these artists’ albums in 2011 has helped boost albums sales, but more importantly they lend a veneer of vitality to the album market that is not accurate.  More typically 21st century artists – the likes of Pitbull, Rihannna, Katy Perry and LMFAO – will be measuring their 2011 success in terms of singles sales, live sales, merchandize revenue, YouTube views and Facebook likes.

Rumours of the CDs’s demise are much exaggerated…perhaps. Of course the album is far from dead – after all, as we have seen, the CD remains the bedrock of music sales – but it is becoming just one, weakening, part of a broader mix of artist revenues.  In some ways artists are better protected from the music industry meltdown than record labels: they – along with their managers – are rapidly acquiring new skillsets and business acumen.  Record labels however are left having to put a positive spin on the album’s apparent longevity.  However the fundamental fact remains that the CD is a dying breed.  It may have a good few years left in it yet, but the long term prognosis is terminal.

Innovate, innovate, innovate! Newspapers and record labels are both at a crucial juncture: physical format revenues will continue to pay the bills for the coming years but paradoxically they must pursue radical format and product innovation strategies that will actually hasten the demise of those same physical revenues. If they don’t, record labels and newspapers will find themselves with the lose-lose scenario of depleted physical revenues and pitiful digital income.

Next week I’ll be publishing a free report that lays out the vision for exactly what that format and product innovation needs to look like.

21 thoughts on “Is the Music Industry Going the Way of the Newspaper Industry?

  1. Come on, we all knew album sales are falling, due to the iTunes format and people cherry-picking tracks. The money is still coming in via other revenue streams.

  2. Indeed! but there are a lot of people reading the US upturn and the success of Adele as signs of a Renaissance. To be fair CD declines will bottom out somewhere, and that place will be those residual digital holdouts who will never buy digital. But when they finally dump that old CD player and don’t have anything to replace it with, they’ll just fall out of the music market.

  3. Pingback: Music links 1/11/12 | Deep In the Music

  4. Pingback: Music Links 1/11/12 | The Cross Pollinator

  5. Great blog but I don’t understand the Coldplay\Spotify reasoning. It implies that Spotify’s [mainly younbger] users will buy the album if its not on their preferred service. Is that what you mean and is there evidence of that?

  6. Spotify is used by a broad demographic of users so Coldplay’s concern was that some of their potential album buyers also use the service. (Note that Coldplay are a strong digital album artist than Adele, particularly in the US, so the digital cannibalization concern is bigger for them. Though also worth noting that that Adele’s ’21’ wasn’t on Spotify either). There’s no conclusive evidence to prove that streaming will cannibalize album sales but a body of anecdotal evidence is beginning to build e.g.

  7. Thanks for that. The problem is (as the posts below it say) that the depiction of the proportion of album sales by format is not evidence either way of the effect of witholding music from Spotify on sales. We are in a very complex market where A happening does’t necessarily mean B will follow.

  8. Good piece Mark and useful that you identified that the recently posted figures are all unit sales, not total revenues; like you I suspect that in the US this key number will be down. When these numbers are available it will be interesting to see how much of the total the streaming services make up. I also wonder how much the shares the majors hold in Spotify will be worth in 12 months time, and when the current owners will look for a substantial pay day. Of course the real story then will be that presumably none of that profit will flow back to the artist community.

  9. Webbo: your points are very valid. Indeed there is a case to be made that Spotify is essentially radio for the digital age (yes I know there are *many* actual differences, but as everything undergoes transformation digitally, let’s for the moment use the working hypothesis that Spotify is what radio looks like in the digital age). Once we start at this point a new perspective applies: some people will not buy albums because they hear them on Spotify. Absolutely true, but exactly the same applies to radio. In fact you’ll probably find as many execs at labels who fear the cannibalistic impact of radio as you will those who sing its praises as a marketing channel. The exact same dichotomy applies to Spotify, except that Spotify generates more rights owner interest per play than radio (and for artists too).

    John: following on from the above point, the problem with measuring the impact of Spotify when we see revenue numbers is that Spotify has JV relationships with each major, which means that a significant portion of revenues from Spotify won’t even count as recorded music revenue and won’t show up in market numbers. So whatever the portion streaming accounts for, add some. Though of course not for artists, who don’t get to share in JV income.

  10. Pingback: This week #2 in digital music |

  11. Pingback: The Tale of the CD, the Digital Refusnik and the Charitable Collector

  12. Music will soothe the soul and calm us down when we are upset if we let it. Nothing is better than the sound of something that an individual is blessed to have as a talent.

  13. I blog often and I seriously thank you for your information. Your article has really peaked my interest. I will take a note of your site and keep checking for new information about once a week. I opted in for your Feed as well.

  14. New Yajdi site, get the latest on upcoming shows, booking info, and newest music from Yajdi. follow Yajdi on twitter and facebook.

  15. This website was… how do I say it? Relevant!! Finally I’ve found something which helped me. Kudos! I want to thank to eGoodMarket, after reading the article on their site, I upload some essays and case studies and it works. It is amazing. Thanks guys! Please keep up your good work.

  16. Aw, this was a really nice post. Taking a few minutes and actual effort to produce a really good article… but what can I say… I hesitate a whole lot and don’t seem to get nearly anything done.

  17. After I originally left a comment I seem to have clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and from now on each time a comment is added I recieve four emails with the exact same comment. Is there a way you can remove me from that service? Thanks a lot!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s