Spotify, Apple, YouTube And The Streaming Pincer Movement

The Financial Times yesterday reported that Apple is planning on integrating Beats Music into an iOS update as early as the first quarter of 2015. Which means the entire base of Apple’s 500 odd million iOS devices suddenly become Apple’s acquisition funnel. As I wrote back in May, this was always the strategy Apple was most likely to pursue. Of course being available to 500 iTunes customers is not anything like converting them all. Just ask U2. But it does give Beats Music – if Apple keep the name – a reach like no other subscriptions service on the planet. Especially if Apple is willing to roll out free trials to them all.   Currently just 8% of consumers in the US and UK have experienced a subscription trial, which translates into approximately 30 million people. Even if Apple does not quickly succeed in taking subscriptions to the mainstream it is about to take subscription trials to the mainstream, which is the crucial first step.

streaming pincer

Add this to YouTube’s recently announced Music Key subscription service, which should be aspiring to get 5 million or so subscribers in its first year to be considered a success, and a picture emerges of Spotify squeezed in the middle of a streaming pincer movement (see figure). In the near term Apple will be hoping to win back a lot of its lost high spending iTunes customers from Spotify. Longer term it will be looking to grow the market.

None of this means anything like the end for Spotify. Instead it will force Spotify to up its already high quality game. Competitive markets thrive far more than ones in which one or two key players dominate. It could mean that Spotify’s potential flotation or sale value is tempered for a while, which could push out Spotify’s exit timelines until it has proven its worth in a more competitive marketplace. But Spotify has the distinct advantage of being a) the incumbent and b) a pure play. Spotify, Deezer and Rhapsody are all in this game simply for music. That means each and every one of them has a laser focus on making the best possible music service proposition they can. The same is quite simply not the case for either Apple or YouTube. They will need to leverage that asset in their conversations with rights holders to ensure they are given more flexibility in terms to drive true marketplace innovation and experimentation.

subs numbers 11 14

But Spotify et al would be foolish to underestimate the scale of the challenge they will face. Apple has the largest installed base of digital music buyers on the planet (see figure). As creditable as Spotify’s 12.5 million paying subscribers is, it pales compared to Apple’s 200 million iTunes music buyers. Also Apple has many additional assets at its disposal. Integrating into iOS is just one tactic it can employ. Spotify et al depend on Apple’s platform for much of their survival. But there is no reason Apple has to play truly fair. Amazon set a platform precedent with its treatment of Hachette that Apple will have been watching closely. Don’t expect anything too obvious, but little tricks like tilting app store optimizing in favour of Beats over Spotify can go a long way.

Things are hotting up, no doubt. But Apple’s arrival in the subscription market will take the sector to a whole new level, and a high tide should rise all boats.

11 thoughts on “Spotify, Apple, YouTube And The Streaming Pincer Movement

  1. Charles – It was an out of date chart that has already been changed – but thanks for the catch

  2. All other music providers using Apple devices are already at a huge financial disadvantage as they have to pay 30% of revenues to Apple. Adds insult to injury

  3. Pingback: MI 25: Streaming Pincer 11/20/14 | Back-Up

  4. It will be interesting to see the stance the EU takes on Beats being included in iOS noting the precedent of Microsoft and IE
    Possibly not significant enough to warranty attention,

  5. All any talent that gets “out” for public enjoyment-Entertainment/Performance should be Paid, no matter what Format or technology delivers it, we are talking about the Future of our ‘Culture’.do you want to send a Signal to our young people that Art/Music should be “FREE” ? i think not. we must embrace the thought that Talent Deserves compensation.

  6. Pingback: Tech Getting Big Valuations | LANDsds Sustainable Voice -The NeXuses

  7. Nagyon jó ez a zsebes hús ötlet! 🙂 El tudom képzelni a hentes csodálkozó arcát… :)Mondjuk nálam seºbh©sÃÃrstól nincs esélye a dicsÅ‘ségre, de szerintem pulykával vagy csirkével is működik! Hajjaj, de még hogy el tudom képzelni… :))

  8. arabam 2010 eylül ayından beri otopark’ta her gün 10 lira yazıyor bu gün yarın aff çıkacak diye beklerken otopark parası 1000 lira’yı buldu. yeni aff’ta otopark affıda varmı?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s